investment insights

    China’s new stimulus: Groundhog Day or a fresh dawn?

    China’s new stimulus: Groundhog Day or a fresh dawn?
    John Woods - CIO Asia

    John Woods

    CIO Asia
    Homin Lee - Senior Macro Strategist

    Homin Lee

    Senior Macro Strategist

    Key takeaways

    • Chinese authorities have launched a new package of stimulus measures designed to support real estate and stock markets, and boost investor sentiment
    • The central bank has cut its policy rate by 20 basis points, in line with our expectations, and has further lowered banks’ reserve requirements
    • The biggest surprise was the support for equity markets, in the form of new swap and loan facilities to support stock buying
    • We retain a cautious long-term outlook on China's economy and assets, pending the outcome of the US elections. For risk tolerant investors looking to increase their China-related allocations, selected Hong Kong listed consumer discretionary and communication stocks may be worth considering.

    Chinese stock markets have rebounded after the launch of a coordinated stimulus package from Beijing. We await the outcome of the US elections to reassess our fundamentally cautious outlook and investment positioning on China. For more risk tolerant investors keen to increase exposures to Chinese assets in the interim, several areas may be considered on a tactical investment horizon.

    The People’s Bank of China (PBOC), National Financial Regulatory Administration (NFRA), and China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) announced a package of growth support measures on 24 September in a clear attempt to boost market sentiment. The Shanghai Composite equity market responded positively with the best rally in over four years. Could this new stimulus mark a fresh dawn for China’s economy and assets?

     

    Stimulus package surprises low expectations

    The stimulus package delivered more than we had assumed likely ahead of the US elections. We had thought that Chinese policymakers would opt for only a combination of limited monetary easing and additional regulatory tweaks for the real estate sector in advance of November’s ballot. This is because the negative shock of a possible second Trump term could undo the effects of any such package. That said, and setting aside the US elections, disappointing Chinese economic data and the start of the rate-cutting cycle by the Federal Reserve had both advocated for an earlier move.

    The stimulus package delivered more than we had assumed likely ahead of the US elections

    While the PBOC cut its benchmark short-term interest rate by 20 basis points (bps) to 1.5%, in line with our forecast, it cut banks’ reserve requirement ratio by 50 bps. PBOC Governor Pan Gongsheng also hinted at additional cuts to these ratios should economic conditions warrant.

    More support was announced for the struggling real estate sector. In order to reduce the inventory of unsold homes, the PBOC adjusted the terms of its loan support facility to make it more attractive for local state-owned enterprises to buy unsold homes directly. Authorities will also allow the earlier refinancing of existing mortgages, although on a slightly smaller scale than earlier media reports had suggested. The downpayment ratio for second homes was also lowered from 25% to 15%. Six major banks were promised a boost to their capital.

    The new support scheme for equity markets was a positive surprise. The PBOC has created a swap facility worth 500 billion yuan (CNY), or the equivalent of just over USD 70 bn. Institutional investors including asset managers, funds and insurers can pledge various risk assets as collateral for highly liquid assets, to boost their capacity to buy stocks. This announcement was accompanied by a new facility worth CNY 300 billion, where loans can be used to fund stock buybacks. During the press conference, policymakers hinted at the re-launch of a state-backed market stabilisation fund.

    While the individual measures may seem limited, and resemble those tried before, there was a sense of urgency in their simultaneous announcements. This was a strong attempt to boost flagging investor sentiment. Against profoundly depressed expectations, it could challenge overwhelmingly negative investor positioning. Pressure on the yuan is easing and creating some manoeuvring room for the PBOC to augment its liquidity provision.

    Further consequential measures still unlikely before the US election

    Far more will be needed to change our cautious assessment of China’s medium- to long-term economic trajectory. The most immediate challenge is to stabilise the real estate market, which continues to struggle under falling prices and a glut of unsold or unfinished homes. While the latest policy announcements could induce more state-owned enterprises to absorb some excess housing inventory, households’ demand for housing loans remains extremely weak due to accelerating falls in house prices and lingering doubts about developers.

    Far more will be needed to change our cautious assessment of China’s medium- to long-term economic trajectory

    Possible additional measures could include use by local governments of the proceeds from special bond issuance to buy unsold homes, as they can already do for unused land held by developers. Authorities could use fiscal inducements to make housing more affordable for developers and end-buyers. We believe a more aggressive decision needs to be made about fiscal policy, but that it will probably be postponed to December at the earliest.

    Another fundamental inconsistency that needs to be addressed is the drive for both a strong yuan and credible reflation. China is facing significant deflationary pressures, but a genuine reflationary package that suggests either unlimited provision of funds for real estate or support for stock markets would be negative for the yuan.

    Another fundamental inconsistency that needs to be addressed is the drive for both a strong yuan and credible reflation

    The latest policy measures seem to reflect the search for technical tweaks that avoid addressing this inconsistency. Yet unless Beijing is willing to countenance massive fiscal stimulus, it will likely have to accept a much weaker yuan to address the persistent weakness in prices. For this, however, the US election matters. If China wants to neutralise the impact of any new punitive Trump tariffs, a meaningful one-off yuan devaluation could be necessary. Conversely, if Kamala Harris wins, the dissipation of additional tariff fears could provide an improved backdrop for both Chinese policymakers and the market. Consequential decisions on fiscal or monetary policy therefore will likely wait for the US election, leaving more technical tweaks and monetary policy signals as the interim option.

    Consequential decisions on Chinese fiscal or monetary policy will likely wait for the US election result

    Maintaining a neutral stance on Chinese assets for now

    We currently hold no tactical investments in Chinese assets and keep portfolio allocations at strategic levels. Within emerging market equities, we keep China allocations in line with MSCI indices and focus on listing market and sector selection. We await the outcome of the US elections to reconsider this fundamental view.

    For more risk tolerant investors looking to add China exposure, consumer discretionary and communication services stocks listed on the Hong Kong market, as well as selected luxury and mining stocks may be worth considering. Even if China’s medium-term outlook remains mixed, additional stimulus measures, or a positive turnaround in real estate demand could push these stocks higher. In the same vein, investors could also consider non-Chinese assets with significant exposure to the Chinese economy.

    Important information

    This is a marketing communication issued by Bank Lombard Odier & Co Ltd (hereinafter “Lombard Odier”).
    It is not intended for distribution, publication, or use in any jurisdiction where such distribution, publication, or use would be unlawful, nor is it aimed at any person or entity to whom it would be unlawful to address such a marketing communication.
    Read more.

     

    let's talk.
    share.
    newsletter.